Handy Hill Creamery menu

Handy Hill Creamery’s menu is a delightful celebration of classic American comfort food with a focus on creamy indulgence. Their ice cream, of course, takes center stage—scooped fresh daily, with rich, velvety textures that melt in your mouth. The flavor options are a dream for anyone with a sweet tooth, from nostalgic chocolate and vanilla to creative blends like their salted caramel crunch and seasonal berry cheesecake. Each scoop offers the perfect balance of sweetness, and the chunks of chocolate or swirls of fruit add an extra layer of texture.

But Handy Hill Creamery isn't just about ice cream. The menu also features a variety of savory options that complement their sweet treats beautifully. Their sandwiches are hearty and satisfying, with the classic grilled cheese, golden and crispy on the outside, and gooey on the inside, making it an ideal pairing for a milkshake or a scoop of ice cream. For a more filling option, the club sandwich—stacked with fresh turkey, crisp bacon, and garden-fresh veggies—is a crowd-pleaser.

If you're in the mood for something more substantial, Handy Hill also serves up hearty soups and stews. The creamy potato soup, with its smooth, comforting texture and a generous sprinkling of cheddar and chives, is a favorite during cooler months.

What really stands out about Handy Hill's menu is how thoughtfully it blends nostalgia with modern flavors, making it the kind of place where you can savor the familiar while discovering something new with every visit. Whether you’re looking for a classic treat or a savory bite, Handy Hill Creamery offers a variety that caters to every craving.